Woman dubbed ‘Permit Karen’ after she calls 911 on Black neighbors over patio dispute in NJ

New Jersey
This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

MONTCLAIR, NJ — A New Jersey neighborhood rallied together this week after a White resident called the police on her Black neighbor, falsely accusing him of assault during a heated exchange over patio construction.

Video of the incident, which happened in Montclair on Monday, went viral after it was posted on Facebook.

A woman, identified by neighnors as Susan Schultz, claimed she was assaulted by the homeowner, who she shares a backyard property line with.

Homeowners Fareed and Norrinda Hayat, who are both attorneys, said they attempted to diffuse the situation.
According to them, Schultz has harassed them since they moved to the neighborhood in 2018.

“This was just the latest in a string of interactions which she would come to us and make complaints to us about things we were doing on our property,” Norrinda Hayat told PIX11.

Despite trying to appease her with every complaint she’s had, they say she’s consistently targeted them.

On Monday, Schultz questioned whether they had a permit to build a patio in their backyard.

“This week, the difference was when we were unable to answer her in a time frame she wanted, she attempted to weaponize the police,” Fareed Nassor Hayat said.

While police were called, it neighbor Lisa Korn and others came to the couple’s defense; they witnessed the whole incident and said no assault ever took place.

“There was an interest in inflaming this situation so that she could call the police,” Korn said. “‘Oh ‘I am going to call the police this was an assault’ Really? No,” she said.

Norrinda Hayat said she was grateful that her neighbors stepped up.

“Everybody just recognized the moment that we are in and just how quickly these things could turn dangerous,” she said.

Montclair police confirmed that officers responded to the scene but did not give further details.

The incident happened at a time when social and racial injustices are under the microscope following the death of May 25 death of George Floyd, a Black man, at the hands of police in Minneapolis.

Dr. Gita Zarnegar, a Los Angles based psychiatrist who has not treated Schultz or anyone involved in the incident, said the current climate is leading many people to act out in irrational ways.

“They are doing things that probably, in a healthy state of mind, they would look back and feel a tremendous amount of shame,” she said.

PIX11 made several attempts to speak to Schultz, but no one at her home answered the door or picked up the phone.

There is now an active online campaign to have Schultz , who has now been dubbed online as “Permit Karen,” terminated from her job at the environmental protection agency.

Calls and emails to the agency weren’t immediately returned.

New Jersey Videos

Fighting hunger with peanut butter and jelly in NJ

Gov. Murphy signs bill requiring NJ schools to teach diversity, inclusion

Thursday marks one year since first COVID-19 case in NJ

Devils welcome fans back as NJ arenas, stadiums open with limited capacity

Prudential Center welcomes fans for Devils-Islanders

More New Jersey

Trending Stories

Connect with PIX11 Online

Connect with PIX11 Online

Don't Miss

Latest Video

G Thing: Nose piercing leads to liver transplant

NYC Safe Walks expands to Chinatown to respond to anti-Asian bigotry

New York City movie theaters reopen at limited capacity

Opportunities to get vaccinated improve in NYC, but new problems arise

NY lawmakers modify Cuomo’s emergency COVID-19 powers amid nursing home cover-up, sexual harassment allegations

Weekend weather

Brooklyn seniors in NYCHA clean up raw sewage

Movie theaters reopen in NYC

Convictions overturned in 1996 deaths over withheld reports