Giddy up, Staten Island! Couple gets pet horse after realizing there’s no city law against it

Local News
This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

TOMPKINSVILLE, Staten Island — Hold your horses!

Morgie, the newest resident of Pommer Avenue, is a 12-year-old chestnut mare beloved by some, but not all, of her neigh-bors.

Morgie arrived just six weeks ago when Abdul Elenani and his wife bought their home on a dead-end block and discovered that there is no city law prohibiting horses as pets.

“It’s a passion of mine, a hobby, it relaxes me,” Abdul Elenani, Margie’s owner, told PIX11. “When I come home after a tough day at work at coffee shops, Cocoa Grinder, I put the hay out for her to eat.”

The couple spent close to $5,000 building a stable in their driveway and now try to ride their horse at least every few days.

The only disappointment so far was when Abdul rode Morgie to the drive-through Dunkin’ Donuts; he and the horse he came in on were refused service.

“Medium ice coffee, milk and sugar. Thank you, I’m serious. Hey very serious,” Abdul can be heard saying video of the attempted purchase.

In this neighborhood Morgie already has a colt following.

“She’s a real sweetheart,” Ted Hyde, a neighbor, told PIX11 News. “She’s well cared for. She’s loved. She’s an asset to the neighborhood.”

PIX11 found there is only one nay-sayer on this block, Morgie’s closest next door neighbor.

“It’s six feet away from my kitchen window, Steve Coyne, an unhappy neighbor, told PIX11 News. “It smells. The flies and mosquitoes are crazy. It whinnies all night long. It’s a nuisance.”

The city has received three complaints, but article 161 of the city health code says as long as a horse is used for recreational, non commercial purposes, it’s all OK.

The Elenanis also had a goat, which was against the law. Itleft the premises Thursday.

“I spoke to a lawyer who says even if it’s legal, you can sue them, but it will be costly,” Coyne, the nay-saying Neighbor, told PIX11 News.

But for now, it’s just unbridled passion between Morgie and Abdul, the newest residents of Pommer Avenue.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Connect with PIX11 Online

Connect with PIX11 Online

Trending Stories

Follow us on Facebook

Don't Miss

@PIX11News on Twitter