Girl Scouts cleaning shoreline of Brooklyn creek find 7 dead cats in plastic bags

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

BROOKLYN — A group of Girl Scouts cleaning the shoreline at Gerritsen Creek recently made a horrifying discovery that may shed light on what happened to the 20 missing cats from Industry City in Brooklyn. The scouts found seven dead cats in plastic bags on the beach on Oct. 14.

Troop leader Grace Scotto says it appeared the cats had been in the water.

“All I keep thinking about is ‘how did these cats die’” said Scotto, a self-described cat lover. “Were they poisoned? Were they suffocated in the plastic bags?”

Scotto said the leader of the cleanup reported the finding to the Department of Sanitation.  However, a department spokesman says no such call was received.  At the end of the day, the cats in plastic bags were put out for pickup along with all the trash collected by the scouts during the cleanup.

Scotto, aware of the search for the missing cats from Industry City, posted the scouts’ disturbing findings on Facebook. A number of caretakers of a registered feral cat colony responded. They’ve been trying to find the 20 cats for six weeks, ever since Industry City contracted with Squash Exterminating to move the cats because of a flea problem.

Industry City CEO Andrew Kimball now admits mistakes were made.

“As we now know, the appropriate  handling would have been to work with the cat community here. Secondly, what the contractor should have done is take them to the Animal Care Center and have them treated,” Kimball said. “That obviously didn’t happen.”

The exterminator admitted to trapping and removing the cats from Industry City overnight and then releasing them into two Brooklyn Parks, including Gerritsen Bay, Kimball said.

The colony’s caretakers who saw Scotto’s Facebook posting spoke with her about the cats that were found on the beach.

“It appears it matches up to the same colors of our cats in our colony and this is one of the locations where the exterminator claimed they were dumped” Robert Stevens said. “It’s no coincidence.”

Even if they are part of the colony, that leaves 13 cats still missing.

“It’s been over a month now and I’m not happy with the way the police are handling this,”  caretaker Jen Petito said.

The NYPD’s Animal Cruelty Squad said it is continuing its investigation. The caretakers want to see arrests made.  They say the exterminator’s dumping of the cats appears to be illegal. No one from Squash Exterminating of Brooklyn returned our calls or emails.

If you’ve got a story for me, send an email to

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Brooklyn Videos

'They don’t have money to spend': Brooklyn residents hungry for food, community this Thanksgiving

3 officers injured in 2 incidents Wednesday

Gowanus rezoning, construction isn't without concerns

The Missing: Family pleads for loved one's return 16 years after coming out, going missing

Body found in bag on Brooklyn sidewalk

Woman charged with murder in Brooklyn point-blank shooting after being apprehended in Florida: NYPD

More Brooklyn

Connect with PIX11 Online

Connect with PIX11 Online

Trending Stories

Follow us on Facebook

Don't Miss