Families still want answers in Brooklyn NYCHA serial killer case


BROWNSVILLE, Brooklyn — Police say accused serial killer Kevin Gavin terrorized seniors at the Carter Woodson Houses in Brownsville, allegedly killing three defenseless elderly women over six years.

Each victim was murdered differently, so at first police could not see a pattern.

“It was difficult for police to label the same offender,” said St John’s University criminal justice professor and Retired NYPD Commissioner of Training Dr. Robert Gonzalez.

But Police say DNA evidence linked Gavin to all three victims. The most recent, 78-year-old Jaunita Caballlero, found strangled. Her son made the gruesome discovery.

In 2019, police found 83-year-old Jacolia James dead inside her 11th Floor apartment with head trauma. And in 2015 Myrtle McKinney was found dead on her kitchen floor. Her death was ruled as “natural causes” until a funeral director found a stab wound on the back of her neck.

Families say that both NYCHA and the NYPD have been negligent regarding security.

Gavin’s extensive criminal record put him on the radar. In 1982, police arrested Gavin for criminal possession of a weapon and for at least Six drug offenses From 2002 to 2010, including the sale of narcotics. Again in 2004 for burglary, when police say Gavin broke into a restaurant and stole equipment.

In Brownsville, Gavin befriended all of the victims and ran errands for them. He then brutally turned on them, something Gonzalez says police could not see coming.

“He had quite a few different offenses in his rap sheet, soit was hard for them to label him some type of killer, there was nothing that would tie him to a violent killer.”

Brooklyn Videos

Business booming for Brooklyn liquor store

Community calls for change in NYPD's 75th precinct

Fire on BQE during multi-vehicle crash

Brooklyn mom's home plagued by leaks

Brooklyn's 75th Precinct Shakeup

Bushwick homeowners forced to spend thousands on questionable sidewalk repairs

More Brooklyn

Trending Stories

Connect with PIX11 Online

Connect with PIX11 Online

Don't Miss

Latest Video

The latest on the investigations into Gov. Cuomo

Discovery of 'secret room' puts spotlight on TikTok trend

Vaccine supply increases as two NYC sites go 24 hours

Plant-based community fridge on the Lower East Side helps feed New Yorkers

8 injured, including 2 kids, after van slams into car, outdoor dining area, scaffolding in Midtown: NYPD

'Good Trouble' star Sherry Cola talks hit Freeform series, stand-up comedy

'Real World' reunited: Kevin Powell talks new Paramount+ series

Jon Batiste talks new album, Golden Globe win

Watch with Dan: March docs include 'The Speed Cubers,' 'The Social Dilemma,' and 'Long Shot'