Used car lot plays ‘let’s make a deal’

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

INWOOD, N.Y. — Take a young couple from Pennsylvania, living in Harlem because they have some family issues. Add in two young children, no work, and bad credit. Now toss in a used car dealer who has a “deal” for them.

You know what you have? A total utter debacle.

Jose Batiz and Dominique Oneal traded in their 2000 Honda Accord for a 2005. When all was said and done they agreed to a 23.99 percent interest rate and the total cost of this 10-year-old car with more than 114,000 miles would be more than $23,000!

“When we first got the car it had a cracked windshield and something was wrong with the power steering, “ Dominique told me. “Looking back at the advertisement, the car did not have a cracked windshield…They fixed the car supposedly, they fixed the pump. And when my husband was driving it home the car was worse than before.”

And when they took it to their own mechanic:

“They said the front and back tires are bad. The rotors. The brakes. The power steering pressure hose. A bushing and a control arm. They suggested a timing belt and motor mount.”

And to top it off, they say at first they didn’t get a temporary registration.  Eventually they got one from New Jersey and they’d still have to get the car registered in Pennsylvania where they live.
So we paid a little visit to the dealership Five Towns Drive in Inwood, Long Island.  The boss is a guy named Malik or Mark.  But by any name he’s a piece of work.

You’ve got to look at the video. I went around with him for a long time. He kept changing his mind.  At one point, in 90 degree heat with Jose and Dominique’s two small children there he refused to return their trade in and refused a refund, leaving them stranded.

That’s when I called the police.

With the aid of the Nassau County PD Malik agreed to return the couple’s car and 15-hundred dollars after he received the Pennsylvania registration. But then a couple of days later, the dealership called Dominique. Malik denied offering a refund. She recorded the conversation.

Malik:  "I can't return the car.  Not after you did."

Dominique: "What did I do to you? I'm just trying to get my money back that you promised me that you would give me."

Malik:  "I didn't promise you anything."

So this is where Dominique and Jose are now.  In a terrible situation thanks to this guy Malik who has no problem telling them one thing and then denying it.

Want a piece of advice? If you’re buying a used car go to a factory authorized dealer.  It may help you avoid characters like this.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.