EXCLUSIVE: Police report in Eric Garner’s death conflicts with videos, witnesses

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

STATEN ISLAND (PIX11) - A police report obtained by PIX11 about Eric Garner’s deadly arrest outlines something very different from what videos show.

The police report compiled by a commanding officer in the investigation unit on Staten Island describes how Eric Garner resisted arrest. Officers Pantaleo and Justin D’Amico also claim they had to get control of Garner, but never mentioned the use of a chokehold.

“He started choking on him,” a witness said. “Like real bad.”

The report also reveals the supervising officer who responded to the scene in plainclothes, believed to be Sergeant Dhanan Saminath, arrived on the scene once Garner was down.

The sergeant said he “did not observe the perpetrator (Garner) make any statements” and “did not appear to be in great distress.”

Another female sergeant, Kizzy Adoni, made a similar statement in the report. She “believed she heard” Garner say he was having difficulty breathing. Adoni also said “The perpetrator’s condition did not seem serious and he did not appear to get worse.”

But several videos documenting the incident show Garner clearly stating he cannot breathe at least eight times. At one point he is unresponsive.

Sgt. Saminath mentions he called EMS because Garner was having difficulty breathing, which conflicts with his earlier statement that Garner did not appear to be in great distress.

People are now questioning how the police report can turn out to be so different from what videos show.

“You have a report that is stating that the sergeants were at the scene and the actions that they took was totally different from what the video states,” former NYPD detective and President of the Law Enforcement Alliance, Dennis Jones says.

Jones calls the report disturbing and hopes the conflicting statements are not part of a cover-up.

“The department is not wrapped around just this one incident,” Jones says. “We truly believe and have faith that this investigation is going to continue on.”

The NYPD did not comment when contacted by PIX11. Normally, the NYPD cannot comment during an open investigation.


  • Jon Taylor

    The reason for the discrepancy is that police reports are constructed not to give an accurate and unbiased account of what happened, but to construct a version of events that will cast themselves in the most favorable light.

    One has to wonder whether it’s the majority of resisting arrests that are so utterly fabricated, or pretty much all of them.

    Our justice system is based on believing the word of professional liars.

  • Center Stage


    a.) Vote for politicians willing to put laws on the books that will protect the people from police brutality.

    b.) Go to your city council meetings and tell them about cases of abuse of force from your local police department

    c.) Write the MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL and CITY MANAGER about cases of police abuse

    d.) Demand a NEW police chief if the one you have refuses to fire bad officers

    e.) Videotape your encounters with police

    f.) ALWAYS file complaints with internal affairs on abusive police officers – make certain there is a paper trail on bad cops

    g.) Document everything with date, time, witnesses, officer’s name, officer’s badge #, officer’s squad car # (Who, What, When, Where and How)

    h.) make multiple copies of everything – keep additional copies with friend or relative

    i.) Do rallies

    j.) Do petitions

    k.) File lawsuits against cases of police abuse

    l.) Ask your pastors to get involved

    m.) Make certain to NEVER resist arrest

    n.) Support leaders on the front line fighting for citizen’s rights

    o.) Start organizations to combat police brutality

    p.) DEMAND all officers wear cameras

    q.) DEMAND dash cam videos be activated on all police stops

    r.) DEMAND all officers receive re-TRAINING on diversity

    s.) DEMAND all officers receive re-TRAINING on USE OF FORCE

    t.) DEMAND your police chiefs come out into the communities and listen to the citizen’s concerns about issues with their officers

    u.) DEMAND a THREE STRIKES YOU’RE OUT on bad officers

    v.) DEMAND police associations stop helping bad apples get their jobs back when their records support firing as the best option

    w.) DEMAND police associations hold officers to a higher standard

    x.) DEMAND officers submit police reports on incidents involving use of force within 24 hours

    y.) DEMAND officers submit police reports of incidents involving deadly force within 24 hours

    z.) DEMAND officers receive random drug test and psychological evaluations

  • The Truth (@ITellzTheTruth)

    Well Well Well Why doesnt this shock or surprise me at all.They tried to cover this murder up, thats why They are so arrogant and stupid they didnt think all these videos were gonna go viral…An show the real truth..I hope they all rot in hell..An I hope Officer Danny pays dearly, with his corrupt ass!!!

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.