Teen stabbing suspect acted in self defense: lawyer

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

THE BRONX (PIX11) — A lawyer for a 14-year-old boy accused of stabbing his classmate to death at their Bronx school said his young client was acting in self defense, and loved ones allege the suspect was a victim of bullying.

“He’s a great kid. He’s a good kid,” said Christopher Paulino, who knows Noel Estevez.

Estevez, 14, is accused of killing his classmate at IS 117 after school Thursday afternoon.

Thursday morning, just yards from where the stabbing took place, school police were out in force.

The 14-year-old victim, Timothy Crump, reportedly lived with his mother a few miles away from the school.

At Estevez’s building, which sits blocks away from Yankee Stadium, Paulino said Estevez did not have much of a life at home.

“He’s hardly seen his mom. His mom was always in jail or if not, doing stupid stuff and his father is never around, either. He’s always working,” Paulino said.

Paulino added that as a result of spending most of his time alone, Estevez latched onto what he called the wrong group of friends.

Paulino along with the building’s super and a woman who knew Estevez and his father told PIX11 News the 14-year-old had just left a hospital stay for mental issues that lasted about three weeks. In addition, they all said Estevez was the victim of harsh bullying by his so-called friends at school and in the neighborhood.

“They’d piss on his door. They’d wait for him to go to school in the morning in order to pick on him. I’ve seen it before, but they were his friends. They would also be with him,” Paulino said.

The Bronx District Attorney is charging Estevez as an adult which caught one world renowned forensic psychiatrist by surprise.

“This may be a bit heavy-handed,” Dr. N.G. Berril said.

Berril, who is not affiliated with the case, told PIX11 News that bullying in kids produces different results than with adults.

“Kids by nature are more impulsive than adults. They take things to heart,” he said.

Once the mental state of Estevez is taken into consideration, Berrill said there are still too many unanswered questions.

“Was he on his medicines? Who was monitoring this kid? Was the school aware of the fact that he needed to be on medicine? So there are so many questions and so many issues that still need to be explored,” Berrill said.


  • John

    I have not read the story, I can’t. Pix11 needs to fire someone on their web team. Most of the ads load, and all sorts of other junk comes on the screen, but not the story. Idiots! News sites need to prioritize the story and toss the junk, instead all I’m getting is garbage and the ability to post a comment. By the way, comments are not displaying either. Given these conditions, what would you expect me post?

    • Chris

      John, page loads fine here, without ad-block as well with ad-block on. I would check your browser as well flash, but most of all just get an ad-blocker. Mostly loading extra (ads) can cause issues. Stop blaming these guys, the whole system is not infallible.

  • JimC

    I love how we are slowing allowing “bullying” to become some sort of “get out of jail free card” in America. Who cares if you get picked on, that doesn’t give you the right to premeditated murder or assault. Lock this kid up forever, he is already stabbing people to death at 14, there is no therapy around that can fix what is wrong with him, he will forever be a ticking time bomb.

  • carmen'Babylove Pena

     Estevez did not have much of a life at home He’s hardly seen his mom. His mom was always in jail or if not, doing stupid stuff and his father is never around, either. So who the kid looked up to no one no wonder he had mental issues , no one showed him love and didnt teach him rite from wrong obviouly his mom has to b a junkie and his pops never home ya didnt know what the kid went threw at home he acted it out by being agressive. Towards other people

  • lisa


Comments are closed.