PIX11 NOW: Get PIX11 News and weather on Roku, Apple TV, Android TV, Amazon Fire and Amazon Alexa

Spooked horse gets pinned under broken carriage in Columbus Circle traffic

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.
Carriage Thumb


A horse was trapped under its carriage after it was apparently startled on its way up 8th Ave. to Columbus Circle Thursday, according to witnesses.

Around 10:15 a.m. something spooked the horse near the intersection of Eighth Avenue and 57th Street — the driver reportedly lost control and hit a car, causing the carriage to flip onto the horse, pinning its hind legs.

The driver, identified by DNAinfo as 43-year-old Frank Luo, claims the horse suddenly started “acting crazy” and kicking wildly before the accident.  During the struggle the horse broke the front of the carriage and the fifth wheel, Luo said, and became trapped by the harness.

Luo and a passerby helped pull the broken white carriage off the struggling horse, whose name is Chris, and cut off the harness.  The horse is in good condition, according to police, after being evaluated at a nearby stable.

Carriage leading away

Just the most recent incident involving a horse-drawn carriage, last August a six-year-old horse named Oreo broke loose from his carriage and bolted four blocks — from Columbus Circle, all the way to 57th street and Ninth Avenue.

Watch the report from August, 2012:


The horse-drawn carriage industry in NYC has been the focus of multiple protests over the years and both Mayoral candidates Bill de Blasio and Joe Lhota have said that they would ban them.

“I don’t think the horses should be there,” Lhota said in an interview with HuffPost Live, “I think we need to motorize the carriages, similar to what they’ve done in other parts.”  Lhota said he could appreciate the romanticism of ride down Central Park South in a traditional carriage, but added, “I think the horses go through a tremendous amount of trauma and I think we need to think about animal rights.”


“There is simply no way to protect a 1,200 lb animal from oncoming traffic, and today’s incident demonstrates yet another reason why horse drawn carriages need to be taken off the streets now,” Allie Feldman, Executive Director of NYCLASS, an animal advocacy group, said. “Horse drawn carriages are not just inhumane and arcane, they pose a danger to the horse, the passengers and nearby pedestrians.”


  • Debbie

    Horses do not belong in these types of environments – they are flight animals in nature and should be in a stable or pasture allowed to just be a horse! I cannot believe all of the people standing around taking pictures and videos on their phone, instead of trying to help. Thank goodness to those that did, you saved this poor horse's life. And all of this for what, to carry our lazy —- around town!

  • Donna Codyko

    This is ridiculous… how many times does this have to happen? when someone gets hurt, whether the horse or a person.. Mr. Bloomberg, are you prepared to pay up??? Because someone will sue the city- you wait. This is a dangerous tourist trap and shame on you for not ending this after multiple episodes.

  • Guest

    Probably the same ones who will be horrified when the horses are put down or sent for food processing because they no longer have a career. A horse wo one is food or disposed of.

  • Spence

    Enough of having these horses getting injured or killed for taxing around a cart, and exposed to being hit by vehicles.

  • Nashville Internet Marketing

    Simply want to say your article is as surprising.
    The clarity in your post is simply spectacular and i could assume
    you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post.
    Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

Comments are closed.